Corner Shelves vs. Shower Niche: Which is Best for Your Bathroom?

When it comes to shower storage, two of the most popular options are corner shelves and the built-in shower niche. Both offer convenient ways to keep toiletries organized, but they come with their own pros and cons. If you're planning a bathroom remodel or simply looking to upgrade your shower space, this comparison will help you decide which option is best for you.

Corner Shelves: Space-Saving and Versatile

Pros:

1. Easy Installation – Corner shelves can be woven into your shower update.
2. Cost-Effective – They are generally more affordable than built-in niches since they don’t require major construction work.
3. Variety of Materials – Available in glass, metal, plastic, ceramic, or stone to match any bathroom style.
4. Adjustable Placement – You can install multiple shelves at different heights to accommodate various-sized bottles and accessories. You can also position them lower to serve as a step for shaving.
5. Ideal for Small Showers – They make use of otherwise unused space without taking up valuable wall area.

Cons:

1. Can Look Bulky – Depending on the design, some shelves may stick out and disrupt the clean lines of a modern shower.
2. Less Built-In Aesthetic – Corner shelves tend to be more noticeable compared to a recessed niche, which blends seamlessly into the wall.
3. Potential for Mold and Water Buildup – If not properly sealed, water can collect around the edges, leading to mold and mildew.

Shower Niche: Sleek and Built-In Storage

Pros:

1. Aesthetic Appeal – A shower niche is built into the wall, creating a streamlined and minimalist look.
2. Customizable Sizes and Designs – Niches can be tailored to fit your storage needs, and can also have shelving within.
3. Maximizes Space – Since it’s recessed into the wall, a niche doesn’t intrude into the shower area, making it a great space-saving solution.
4. Less Risk of Knocked-Over Bottles – With a designated space for products, you won’t have to worry about bottles tipping over.
5. Adds Value to Your Home – A well-designed niche is a desirable feature that enhances the overall aesthetic and functionality of the shower.
6. Lighted Option -  You can add even more flare to this feature by making it lighted.

Cons:

1. Requires Planning and Construction – Niches must be built into the shower wall, meaning they need to be planned during the remodel or new construction phase.
2. Higher Cost – Due to the additional labor and materials, installing a shower niche is generally more expensive than adding corner shelves.
3. Limited Placement Options – The location of plumbing, studs, and waterproofing can restrict where a niche can be placed.
4. Difficult to Modify Later – Unlike shelves that can be easily changed or removed, niches are permanent once installed.

Which One Should You Choose?

The decision between corner shelves and a shower niche largely depends on your budget, shower space, and aesthetic preferences.

• Choose Corner Shelves if you want more placement options or more affordable storage.
• Choose a Shower Niche if you’re opting for something more seamless, trendy, and easier to hide from view.
• Why not both? If space and layout allows, some homeowners make the most of the offerings of both options!

Both options offer practical shower storage, so the best choice is the one that fits your specific needs and style. Whether you go for corner shelves or a shower niche, ensuring proper waterproofing and material selection will help maintain a clean and functional bathroom. Our team at Bath Tune-Up offers both options as part of your shower remodel in multiple sizes, styles and materials.

Find your nearest location and schedule your free consultation today!